Showing posts with label young adult. Show all posts
Showing posts with label young adult. Show all posts

Tuesday, 11 February 2014

Eleanor and Park - Rainbow Rowell


Something that really angers me is when people patronise young people in the arts.  Whether it is people like Mary Whitehouse trying to censor Doctor Who or Colorado school boards attempting to ban the reading of John Green’s Looking for Alaska, there seems no shortage of old people, in the name of ‘protecting the innocence of the innocent’ attempting to prevent young people from being exposed to some of the hard realities in this world.  Wrapping people in cotton-wool does them no good and risks creating literature for young people that is so bland that they will never be captivated by the wonderful world of literature.

Young Adult literature has a tremendous duty to produce work aimed at younger readers that does not shy away from the controversial, the cruel or from what will make them cry and there are many books out there that do not fulfil this basic need.  Thankfully, there are a few that do step up and one such is this weeks book: Rainbow Rowell’s Eleaonor and Park.



Occasionally a book comes along that just takes your breath away; something so good, so powerful that you cannot stop thinking about it.  These do not come along everyday, making them all the more special when they do appear.  This is one such book.  This is a book about first love between two social outcasts.  So far, so ordinary.  Park is a half-Korean in-betweener, not hugely popular, but not an outcast either.  He comes from a loving family (ish) and mainly just tries to get through the day without causing too much of a fuss.  This all changes when a new girl comes onto his school bus.  

Eleanor is a truly wonderful character - wonderfully fleshed and nuanced.  She is a 'big' girl, not unhealthily so, but enough to attract comment in our rather judgemental world.  Her home life is hell.  Her step-father is abusive to her mother, her mother is a shadow of her old self and is getting by the best she can - but is weak.  Her father is uninterested.  Her siblings are cowed.  She is alone in a tiny house in a room shared by all her siblings.  She has no escape.  That is until Park comes along.

I am not going to say too much about the plot of the book because you NEED to read it to believe it.  Suffice to say it is far from just another YA love story.  It contains all of the usual ingredients: late-teen boy and girl, difficult high school, parents in the way etc.  But the story is all about the obstacles; the roadblocks placed in the way by society.  They are forced to confront situations that frankly no one should have to face, but least of all people so young.  The description of the abuse suffered by Eleanor at home and at school is close to harrowing.

The style of the story is a dual POV with Eleanor and Park telling alternately the story in a chronological manner.  This works brilliantly as it gives you the sense that you are getting two different novels at once - indeed she could have released the two halves separately and they still would have stood up.  They tell the stories from a position of love and understanding, but also from the fact that they have very different perspectives due to their wildly divergent upbringing.

There is swearing and Rowell doesn't pull her punches in her description of the horror of Eleanor's home-life, but it would be criminal to say this was not suitable for young readers, though maybe not pre-teens.  There is horror in this world: fear and pain, but simply veiling the eyes of the young from it will only make them ignorant of it when it eventually confronts them.  This book is a testament to how love conquers all and how bravery defeats fear, and to reject it just because it says 'fuck' every now would be just the most terrible shame.

Rowell is a very gifted writer, and the way she weaves the story of abuse and fear around this truly beautiful love story is really quite something.  Her characters are sometimes brutal, but never caricatures or stereotypes.  They are recognisable but unique.  This story is quite simply brilliant.  I never thought that I would read a YA adult story as sad and as beautiful as The Fault in Our Stars.  This is as good and then some.

I don't care what you are reading or what you are interested in.  You have to read this book and I mean right now!

9/10

Favourite Quotes

“Holding Eleanor's hand was like holding a butterfly. Or a heartbeat. Like holding something complete, and completely alive.”

“You saved me life, she tried to tell him. Not forever, not for good. Probably just temporarily. But you saved my life, and now I'm yours. The me that's me right now is yours. Always.” 

“Don't bite his face, Eleanor told herself. It's disturbing and needy and never happens in situation comedies or movies that end with big kisses.” 
Read More »

Tuesday, 28 January 2014

The Rehersal - Eleanor Catton

I am usually intensely distrustful of 'literary' books.  I often find that they put showing-off ahead of telling a good story.  Clever writing techniques do not necessarily lead to good storytelling.  That is not to say that I am a total philistine – I just like my books to be understandable to those of us mere mortals without degrees in English Literature.  The truly great 'literary' books are those that use imaginative techniques and strategies to tell a story, rather than the story being incidental to those techniques.

Eleanor Catton's Man Booker Prize winning book The Luminaries was often damned in some quarters with the compliment "a triumph of style".  I have not personally read it myself, but knowing something of it, I can see how people may come to that conclusion.  This made me a little nervous about giving her debut novel The Rehersal a go, but having done some research I thought it worth a try.

Now first things first: a confession.  I like Ellie Catton (yes I did just call her Ellie).  I was actually interning at Granta Books when The Luminaries won the Booker Prize and had the pleasure of not only meeting her and her partner but we also all went out boozing together.  She is one of the nicest and most genuine people I have ever had the pleasure of meeting and I cannot rule out the possibility that this review may be influenced by her being a gem.



The Rehersal tells two parallel stories: that of an elite, slightly Darwinian, drama school and that of a high school in the grips of a teacher/pupil sex scandal.  All of the characters are like open books, like characters in a play.  They keep very little to themselves and articulate every emotion to each other in a very clear and evocative manner.  It is told in a constantly shuffling time scale, moving between months and years constantly, which makes the plot a little difficult to follow but equally keeping the story moving along at a good pace.  Catton never reveals anything too soon, always ensuring that you are kept guessing.

The central plot point: the affair between Victoria and Mr Saladin is kept secret and mysterious, just as it was to the students in the play and pupils at the school. For the girls at the high school, the affair was a great betrayal of their trust, not because it happened, but that Victoria did not tell them. In that community total secrecy was the taboo. Sex was seen as something that was both intimate between the people involved, but also that deserved public scrutiny - something that is interesting to consider in our world.  Moreover, the characters in the story celebrate crisis: being seen as damaged was desirable and the characters who identify as being 'normal' are outcast which is another really interesting thought that Catton throws up.

The storyline in the theatre school is a little less focussed.  While the descriptions of the lessons and attitudes of the teachers were my favourite parts of the book, I felt that it did not marry well with the rest of the plot.  The spine of the story are saxophone lessons given to many of the main characters by an unnamed teacher who has a seemingly unhealthy fascination with the lives of her young charges.  There is clearly some potent symbolism here, but I was not unable to unearth it: it was possibly a little over my head.


Though at times I felt the book to be a little over my head, I loved this book, especially how the characters are completely open with little thought of social propriety, and the examination it contains of teenage social interaction and life is truly something to behold. While this is not my usual genre, I would recommend this to any reader who is willing to dedicate some time and thought to a book.  Trust me, it is well worth it!

8/10

Favourite Quotes
“She is a loner, too bright for the slutty girls and too savage for the bright girls, haunting the edges and corners of the school like a sullen disillusioned ghost” 

“Remember that anybody who is clever enough to set you free is clever enough to enslave you.” 



“Gaining control isn't the exciting part. Sleeping with a minor isn't exciting because you get to boss them around. It's exciting because you're risking so much. And taking a risk is exciting because of the possibility that you might lose, not the possibility that you might win.” 

“The stage is not real life, and the stage is not a copy of real life. Just like the statue , the stage is only a place where things are made present. Things that would not ordinarily happen are made to happen on stage. The stage is a site at which people can access things that would otherwise not be available to them. The stage is a place where we can witness things in such a way that it becomes unnecessary for us to feel or perform these things ourselves.” 
Read More »

Friday, 10 January 2014

Walk Me Home - Catherine Ryan Hyde

We live in a society that demands leadership; that is in love with decisive action.  If you go to your local bookshop and look at any book on self-help title, that's what it'll tell you to do.  Make your mind up and make a decision!  The my favourite one is from Teddy Roosevelt: " In any moment of decision, the best thing you can do is the right thing, the next best thing is the wrong thing, and the worst thing you can do is nothing."  The problem is that most of us are wrong about most things most of the time.  Of course we are, it's how we learn.  What happens though if life-or-death decisions about your life, and that of your little sister are thrown to you when you're just 16?  Well I imagine you'd say you'd be screwed.  Well, that just about summarises my latest book:



Walk Me Home is the latest book by Catherine Ryan Hyde, though it is the first of hers that I have read.  Straddling the divide between YA and Adult Contemporary, it tells the story of Carly and Jen: two sisters who are travelling from New Mexico to California on foot as they flee towards the only responsible adult they have ever known in an attempt to avoid going into care.  Their father is long-since gone, their mother is recently gone (for reasons that are explained later and I will not spoil), and the only adult left in their lives is Teddy - a man who Carly loves and trusts beyond all else, but Jen has reasons to say otherwise - who lives hundreds of miles away and is uncontactable.  They had no money, no transport and frankly no hope. 

After escaping starvation and assaulty/rapey adults (and some nice ones as well) they find a cranky yet kindly old American Indian woman who takes them in despite her catching them stealing from her hen house.  Jen is a fan, Carly is not, leading to the sisters splitting before fate intervening to reunite them at the end.
 
The first thing that I would say about this book is that you have to suspend that part of your brain that tells you that this realistic or believable.  The plot is frankly a little ridiculous and the characters it has to be said are hardly original.  However, there are good facets to this book that I did enjoy.

The first is the drip-drip nature of the story telling.  It is written in a flashback style, with part of the story being told in the present, and the other being about six months in the past.  This means that at the start you have no idea why the girls are fleeing or what it is they are fleeing from.  As the plot progresses then the pieces of the puzzle begin to fit together and you start to build the picture, but just as the girls are confused about what is going on, so is the reader.  they don't know who to trust or who to believe, and likewise neither do you.  To quote Blackadder : "it twists and turns like a... twisty turny thing".

The second facet that I liked brings me back to what I was talking about at the start.  Responsibility was thrust upon Carly as the elder sister but, just like Lizzie Bennet in many ways, she is blinded by her own prejudices.  She hates her mother and doesn't believe a word she ever said.  She implicitly trusts Teddy despite mounting evidence to suggest he is a ne'er-do-well.  She insists on trusting no one else and on keeping on travelling, despite appearances that that may be a little suicidal.  With Carly it's her way or the highway (in fact its more her way AND the highway).  She is incredibly tunnel-visioned, and that is both what keeps her and Jen alive, but also what leads them into great danger.  She doesn't know who to trust, so she trusts no one but Teddy.  While this may not be a terribly original character, she is a very interesting one as she is intensely flawed.

This is in many ways a classic coming-of-age story with a very readable style which never reveals too much; keeping you hooked.   It is a story about 'Home' and where to find it when your life is seemingly lost.  It is a tale of hope and optimism in the face of crushing odds which pushes all of the emotional buttons with more twists than a Cornish country lane.  It's faults are many, focussed around the fact that most of the characters fail to act in any sense rationally, but this does not stop this from being an enjoyable read.

7/10
Read More »

Saturday, 4 January 2014

Unbreakable - Kami Garcia

Anyone who has been to university knows that there are two basic academic groups: the Science students and the Arts students.  There are of course some subjects that straddle this great divide such as Psychology, Geography etc but these are the main two.  Now I hope you will please indulge me if I be a little broad and sweeping.  

In general Science students like facts, numbers, theories, equations.  They like something tangible; something that they can follow so that they can add ‘x’ to ‘y’ and get ‘z’.  They like to ask questions and get definite answers, or at least some kind of an answer – preferably one that can be expressed in a few words.  

Arts students, myself included here, do not like this.  We don’t answer questions: we like to say things like “well to an extent that is true but really there are a number of factors...” We like to pooh-pooh so-called facts, saying lines like “facts get in the way of a good narrative.”  Now this is of course because the kinds of questions that we tackle are not the same: they are creations of man, not of nature.  You can come up with an equation to figure out how fast something falls or what time the Sun will rise in the morning, but you can’t create one to explain what makes Mozart’s music enchanting or JRR Tolkein’s works enthralling.  You can’t express art through numbers, be it music, painting, sculpture or literature, yet this has not stopped people from attempting to work out the formulas to the perfect book – the 5 easy steps to telling a best-selling story – and in my view, Kami Garcia has attempted to do just that.


I won a copy of Kami Garcia’s first solo book Unbreakable from a competition on Goodreads.  I entered the contest not really bothering to work out what it was about, just because I fancied a free book.  The cover of it made it look a little silly but it was free so who cares right?  The book is a YA supernatural story about a girl named Kennedy who was living the kind of life that 14 year old female protagonists of YA books always lead: alone, boyfriendless and angsty about it, bookish and devoted to her parents (or in her case parent).  Her life is suddenly torn apart when a demon, latched onto her cat like a plague flea on a rat, kills her mother and she is only saved by a pair of dashing twins who tell her that she was descended from a secret order of, in effect, demon hunters.  

So we have the stereotypical protagonist, in a stereotypical-ish plot and now we are going to hit new levels of lack-of-imagination: the twins.  They are both teenage boys but have different characters: one is level-headed and sweet but a little dull; the other is handsome, dashing and damaged.  Care to hazard a guess where the love interest of this story lies?  Oh these three are not alone.  We also have the bitchy, fightery girl who sees the protagonist as a liability, and the nerd, the technical support guy who is no threat to the protagonist and is merely there to provide cool things.  

The plot, other than a lot of angsting around, is about demon/ghost hunting, specifically about preventing a powerful demon from escaping into our world and it is up to our motley band of barely trained teenagers to do it.  Think Ghostbusters but 15 years old and with worse stuff.  And meaner demons.

I think you so far get at why I think this book isn’t great: it’s as formulaic in structure and characters as the speed of light.  Indeed the plot, up until the end at least, is so incredibly predictable that anyone in any sense familiar with YA literature could tell me the entire plot from a small number of clues.  The characters in many ways are caricatures, not over-blown in any sense but just perfect tropes.  I won’t spoil the plot for you, but frankly you could guess most of it from here.  The ending is actually quite good and rather salvages the overall plot into something rather decent, but really this book, while not riddled with faults, suffers from the very basic problem that it is entirely formulaic.  It is as if Kami Garcia had distilled every YA book that she had ever encountered into a mathematical formula, created an algorithm, inserted the names of each character trope that she wished to include, and pressed “Go”.

The book is not badly written, nor is it a terrible read: it is just bland as all hell.  You finish the book and feel very little from having completed it because you feel that you have already read it before.  It is incredibly lazy storytelling and in some ways makes me a little pissed off because I have no idea why this was published.  Books these days are churned out in their  tens of thousands every year and yet the industry is still struggling and it will continue to struggle if all they produce is mediocre, middle of the road, formulaic works such as this.  This books really is one of those times where I wish that it had been bad – if it had been bad then at least it would have been original.

4.5/10
Read More »

Friday, 8 November 2013

13 Little Blue Envelopes - Maureen Johnson



Anyone that knows me will tell you that I am not a picture of heroic masculinity.  Put me in any situation that involves typically manly pursuits (jar opening, Nazi fighting, press-upping, not crying at musicals) and I will fail faster than Starbuck in a sanity contest (kudos to all that get the reference).  My taste in literature has often been criticised for its girliness not to mention my taste in music, interior decoration and alcoholic beverages, yet even with this propensity, I found my latest book a little challenging.

13 Little Blue Envelopes is a book written by Maureen Johnson and actually by now it is pretty old.  Well actually that isn’t really fair but it was published in 2005 which is, for me, a long time ago – especially given the fact that I usually review books written within the last few years.  Maureen Johnson is famous(ish) to those of you of an American persuasion but I had not heard of her at all until very recently.  My introduction into the world of American Young Adult fiction (largely avoiding stories involving teen vampires) first took me to the world of John Green and through his books I discovered his amazing Youtube channel that he runs with his brother Hank called the ‘Vlogbrothers’.  Now many of you will be intimately familiar with it and will be screaming at me HOW DID IT TAKE YOU THIS LONG TO FIND OUT ABOUT IT??? Well to those people I can only say, I was probably busy playing Football Manager, because that is probably an accurate summary of most of my free time as a teenager.  Anyway (this post is taking even longer than usual to get to the point), through them I was introduced to Maureen Johnson’s books and after some brief Amazoning (surprised that isn’t a verb yet) I decided to start with 13 Little Blue Envelopes.

This is a story about an American girl called Ginny who receives in the mail 13 envelopes, from her recently deceased aunt.  Her aunt is a classic bohemian arty type who has eschewed the rather conservative nature of her family to go gallivanting around Europe.  The first of these letters gives Ginny a credit card with some money and tells her to book a flight to London, leaving all electronic devices behind.  She can only bring one rucksack and can’t bring any maps/guidebooks etc with her and has to open each envelope only after accomplishing each task contained in the previous one.  This leads her on a crazy trip around Europe, seeing her visit, amongst other places: London, Edinburgh and Paris.  The trip itself is a journey of discovery for Ginny in two ways: learning about the life of her aunt and also finding out more of who she is and what she can do whatever misgivings that she may have.

Now, this book is very clearly not marketed at me – I mean it is more closely marketed to me than say a 70 year old ex-navy veteran with a penchant only for whisky and stories involving hard-core nudity – but even so I am clearly not the intended audience here.  My first clue really should have come from the cover.  Generally books aimed at boys are a little less pink (though to be fair she is grasping her thighs in a rather suggestive manner...) The point is that this book is meant to be read by girls like Ginny Blackstone: nervous, timid 14 year old American girls who are trying to find out who they are and want nice boys to like them.  I can’t blame Maureen Johnson for this, those people make up about 80% of the standard readership of YA books.  Normally this is not much of a problem.   I mean I was never an American girl but I can at least identify with the nervous timid bits and even if I could not, the human imagination is a wonderful thing.  Good books manage to appeal to a wide readership, giving everyone no matter who they are a little thing to grab hold of and identify with and the problem with this book is that it doesn’t quite manage that.  The major problem is found in the middle of this book where Ginny falls rather hopelessly for a university drama boy called Keith.  She falls in love in much the same way that Juliet falls for Romeo – hopelessly without much regard for finding out anything about him – and it is at this point the book starts to develop some severe angst, which, in my view, came dangerously close to ruining it.  A little romantic tension is fine, but this was very stereotypical girl-angst, familiar to anyone who has ever been on Myspace (a reference that anyone who wasn’t born between about 1987-1993 is unlikely to get).  This got in the way of what was a rather interesting story and threatened to turn it into something that more closely resembled Twilight fan fiction.

Luckily, this was only a part of this story and it did have many other excellent features.  My personal favourite was the description of Ginny’s time in London – and this is where this book not being aimed at me actually comes full circle and becomes an advantage.  Any Londoner will be familiar with the hilarity that is American tourists.  You can spot them a mile off normally as they are invariably 1) Lost, 2) Wearing shorts in inappropriate weather, 3) Wearing walking-trainers, 4) Loud.  Now Ginny is not all of these things but she rather superbly acts the part of tourist in my city.  She gets baffled by Tube ticket machines (seriously I see this all the time and I have no idea why it is so hard to understand), confused by Harrods (I’m actually with her on this one) and confused by how Ribena works (I had no idea that squash could confused people but apparently this is a real confusion for some non-Brits).  Her experience as a tourist in all these cities, not just mine, made me laugh a lot and in general this was a very funny book, mostly intentionally.

I find that Young Adult books normally – more than other genres – tend to contain significant life lessons; something edifying for its predominantly teenage audience to ponder over after finishing.  This story is mostly about self-belief and finding that there is much more to yourself than you may give credit for.  Ginny spends most of the book saying how she wishes how she was ‘more interesting’, that she had more ‘stories’.  Now this is despite the fact that she followed her aunt’s instructions throughout the book without question, some of which were really quite dangerous in retrospect.  While the teen girl-angst was present, that was not the dominant force of the narrative (thankfully) and it is this part of the story that I most enjoyed.  This was not a moral that was stuffed down your throat.

6.5/10

Favourite Quotes

“She was standing in the airport of Copenhagen, staring at a doorway, trying to figure out if it was (a) a bathroom and (b) what kind of bathroom it was. The door merely said H.
Was she an H? Was H "hers"? It could just as easily be "his". Or "Helicopter Room: Not a Bathroom at All”

“I like you because you were mad. And you're pretty. And pretty sane for a mad person.”

"No shoe should be judged by its footprint, for the foot has a print of its own."
Read More »

Monday, 14 October 2013

City of Bones - Cassandra Clare

image
So this will probably be the last ‘Young Adult’ book that I read for a while as my reading list is filling up with other things. I chose this book largely after seeing the trailer for the upcoming film adaptation and becoming intrigued by the story. I started reading with some trepidation, not least because the cover review was by Stephanie Meyer, the rather divisive author of the teen-girl favourite ‘Twilight’ series. The story is an urban fantasy story that fans of ‘Buffy’ will find instantly familiar. Indeed I would describe this story as a melange of the two. It is set in New York City and follows the a teenage girl Clary as she gets embroiled in the dark underworld of the city. A chance meeting in a night-club with a group of ‘Shadowhunters’ (think ‘slayers’ from ‘Buffy’) sees Clary get embroiled in this complex underworld where shadow slayers live in an uneasy peace with the part-human ‘Downworlders’ (vampires, werewolves, faeries etc.) She finds out that though she thought she was a normal human or ‘mundane’ she was actually part of a family at the centre of an enormous conflict in this underworld.

Now, I fear this review may get negative quite quickly so I shall first talk about the things that I liked about it: Firstly I think the world created by Clare is quite vivid and rich, and I particularly liked a scene in a diner/restaurant where all the various inhabitants of this underworld mingled. It gave a certain sense of community to the story and I love references to food in books. Secondly I liked how the story shifted throughout, starting as a simple search by a daughter for her mother, through a quite boring love-story section (more on that later) and finally into a really very interesting exposition-led history lessons mixed in with breathless fight and chase scenes. Thirdly, I loved the scenes with Luke/Lucian. In a book with characters of dubious depth, I felt his story was the most convincing and the most powerful.

HOWEVER. There are numerous reasons why this book has issues, central among them is the dreaded love triangle. Readers of things like ‘Twilight’ and ‘The Hunger Games’ will be familiar with this incessant requirement in YA fantasy novels with a female lead to be ignorant of two guys falling hopelessly in love with her. While I could just about deal with it in the other two books, in this book it was very tiresome. The combatants in this affair of the heart are:
Clary - Artistic and book loving, launched into an adventure to save the people she cares about. 
Jace - Dangerous and damaged Shadowhunter. Suffers from numerous daddy-issues and outrageously confident in his own looks and charms

Simon - Faithful bff and puppy dog-like kid who ‘proves himself’ when needed.

These tropes are so stereotypical that it slightly hurts my teeth and in my view are entirely unnecessary in a story that does not need it. The bit with Simon declaring his undying love for Clary is particularly awful and I nearly threw the book at the wall while reading it. Other characters have romantic interests which work much better.

Another issue at play is the writing of Clare. I get rather annoyed at people who criticise authors who first cut their teeth in the world of fan-fiction. I think it is a form of intellectual snobbery against a medium that, while is mostly populated by barely literate 13-year olds), also contains many talented and interesting writers. Clare, though I fear is not the greatest or most talented author to emerge from this world. Her use of mixed metaphors/similies etc sometimes beggars belief and she also suffers from ‘swallowed-a-thesaurus syndrome’ where she doesn’t quite understand certain adjectives that she uses making some sentences nonsensical.

To wrap up, this book has a lot of things that made me enjoy it - but I would not recommend it. While the world that Clare creates is interesting and some of the characters created compel, it is mostly fairly derivative. I read the first book, thinking that if I liked it, I would read the rest - but I will not. I can see why some may disagree with me, but I don’t think it’s because I did not ‘get’ it - it’s just that it is not very good.

4.5/10

Favourite Quotes
- “The boy never cried again, and he never forgot what he’d learned: that to love is to destroy, and that to be loved is to be the one destroyed.”
- “The next time you’re planning to injure yourself to get my attention, just remember that a little sweet talk works wonders.”
- “It means ‘Shadowhunters: looking better in black than the widows of our enemies since 1234” 
- “To love is to destroy, and that to be loved is to be the one destroyed”
Read More »

Friday, 11 October 2013

Paper Towns - John Green

image
So any of you who have been following this blog (wow thanks if you have :D) may have noticed that all my reviews so far have been for John Green novels. This is because I have been undergoing a grand introduction to his genius and since the person who is lending the books to me is leaving soon, I have to read through them without gaps in between. If you are not a fan then I apologise and I promise to read someone else soon!

So - ‘Paper Towns’. This is another ‘Young Adult’ story by John Green. It is set in Orlando, Florida in an area of samey Milton Keynes-esque new-builds (I will be using British-isms, suck it up). The main character is Quentin ‘Q’ who lives next door to Margo Roth Spiegelman, a sort of mix of Quin Fabray and Ramona Flowers (I bet no one else mixes a Glee reference with Scott Pilgrim). He developed a crush which quickly became an infatuation with this girl after they shared the trauma of finding a dead body together as kids, and this quickly envelops him. He also has two close friends: Ben, an extroverted nerdy kid and Radar, a cooler yet still nerdy kid who is obsessed with editing an online encyclopedia called Omnictionary (so blatently not Wikipedia…).

The basic premise is that Margo, who has always been dreaming of skipping town - and has already done so several times - disappears just before graduation from high school, shortly after leading Q on a whirlwind adventure of revenge against those that ‘wronged’ her including her cheating boyfriend, her ‘traitorous’ friends as well as tying up some other loose ends. Her disappearance terrifies Q who does not know whether she wants him to find her, or whether she is dead. Thus the book becomes a mystery story: Where is Margo Roth Spiegelman? Who is Margo Roth Spiegelman? Where did she go? Why did she go? Is she dead? Does she want to be found?

There are numerous themes within this books, and many of them are shared between books. The first is the *sigh* ‘Manic Pixie Dream Girl’ character (I hate that word and all of its sparkly pony dustiness). Like Alaska Young from ‘Looking for Alaska’, the main character is obsessed with this mystical entity tied up in a girl. Like Romeo’s obsession with Rosaline (yes I can relate things to Shakespeare), the main character’s infatuation is without serious base. It is the obsession with the idea of the girl rather than the girl itself. Margo is this force of nature, a character who transcends her identity because of the she legend built up.
Another theme is death. This is less obvious than in ‘Fault in Our Stars’ or ‘Looking for Alaska’, but it definitely there. There is 1) the dead man at the start of the story, 2) there are the dead/unused new-builds that Margo directs Q to 3) the near death experience that Q experiences towards the end of the book and 4) the fact that at various points the characters believe Margo to have committed suicide. It is not all-pervasive as a theme, but it always in the background.

Finally though, and this is a true shocker in a book about teenagers about to graduate from high school, this book is really for me about growing up. Q’s friends in the story all seem to be people developing much needed social skills, leaving their insular group of friends and interacting more with the wider school community. Q’s voyage of discovery is about finding out who the girl of his fantasies really is and dispelling the idealised portrait he has of her. And Margo… well there is no way of going into detail without spoiling, but it is rather obvious on reading the book.

So to my views. Well I enjoyed this the least out of the Green books that I have read so far for a couple of good reasons, chief amongst which is that I really did not like the main character. I think Green never quite convinced me why this boy would be so fixated on chasing the girl; why would he give up so much of his time and sanity on chasing her? I get the fact that he idolises and idealises her, and that he thinks that she may be dead but even so, it just never made sense to me. I did not related to him in the same way that I was able to with Pudge or Hazel. I also just felt the story was a hodge-podge of different ideas that didn’t quite click. The 3 sections are very differently paced and styled in varying ways which made the narrative a little disjointed. Overall I think Green tried to accomplish too many things in one book. HOWEVER, that is not to say I did not enjoy the book. It still had those wonderful John Green touches in the narrative and dialogue that cannot fail to make you laugh, and the final part of the book is a masterful example of how to tie up a complex mystery story in a way that is very satisfying and edifying. 
7/10

P.S. I look forward to my final John Green read, but I think I will take a break first… what to read next??

Favourite Quotes- “If you don’t imagine, nothing ever happens at all.”

- “Peeing is like a good book in that it is very, very hard to stop once you start.” 
- “Those of us who frequent the band room have long suspected that Becca maintains her lovely figure by eating nothing but the souls of kittens and the dreams of impoverished children.” 
- “Poetry is just so emo,’ he said. ‘Oh, the pain. The pain. It always rains. In my soul.” 
- “Angela, I really like you, but there’s something you need to know: when we go to my house and hook up, we’ll be watched by the twenty-four hundred eyes of twelve hundred black Santas.” 
- “As far as I can tell, there are two basic (kissing) rules: 1. Don’t bite anything without permission. 2. The human tongue is like wasabi: it’s very powerful, and should be used sparingly.” 
- “Margo was not a miracle. She was not an adventure. She was not a fine and precious thing. She was a girl.” 
Read More »

Tuesday, 8 October 2013

Looking for Alaska - John Green

This summary is not available. Please click here to view the post.
Read More »

Sunday, 6 October 2013

The Fault in Our Stars - John Green

image
I was given this book to read by the wonderful and beautiful Kaitlyn from onadarklingplain.tumblr.com who is a big fan of John Green. With him (and her) being a Liverpool FC fan I was initially skeptical (as he clearly has poor judgement and taste when it comes to football) and this was only increased when I found out the premise of the book.

Essentially this book is about a 16-year-old girl called Hazel who is suffering/recovering from cancer and who falls in love with a fellow sufferer called Augustus Waters. Now from that brief synopsis you would expect this to be either a heart-warming tale of triumph-over-adversity by a dedicated hero who never complains etc etc OR it be a tragic story of a life cut short by cruel fate blah-blah-blah. In fact, on the face of it, this story is nothing like those things. Indeed our heroes both actively rebel against these stereotypes. At one point in the book one of them remarks that most people in the world are not self-less, non-complaining, brave people and that doesn’t change once you get cancer.

The girl Hazel though is acutely aware of her own mortality, she once compares herself to a grenade ready to explode but she is also keen to live her life in the way that she wants too. Being a cancer-sufferer does not stop her from being a teenager either. She is just as irrational, as rebellious against authority and as insecure as any teenager - she just happens to live with a life-threatening illness.

The most surprising and most rewarding thing about the book though is its humour. To make a situation like this story as funny as John Green has takes real skill and it takes real balls too. The closest thing that I can compare it too is the Roberto Bengnini film Life is Beautiful. Like that film, it is a story set in terrible circumstances, but told in a very witty and amusing way. The dialogue between the characters is very easy and well written and you never feel like any of them are really caricatures (except for perhaps Hazel’s friend Kaitlyn). At its heart, this is a love story between two teenagers trying to live in a world that has dealt them a bad hand. They go on adventures and experience loss and pain but most importantly they experience love.

I have few criticisms of this book, but there are a couple. The humour dies away a little towards the end of the story as the whole tone gets a little darker. I understand perhaps what the author was doing there, but there were a few moments where I was wondering if I’d slipped into a different story as the ‘crying’ moments started to overwhelm the ‘laughing’ moments. He also weirdly slips into play script style when writing dialogue exchanges. I’m sure there is some pretentious ‘English student’ word for this, but I thought it a little pretentious.

Overall however, I would strongly recommend this book if only because you will not believe how a story about cancer-suffering teenagers will make you laugh. It is very clever, very funny and a wonderful summer read.

9/10
Favourite Quotes
- “Grief does not change you, Hazel. It reveals you.” 

- “Some people don’t understand the promises they’re making when they make them,” I said.
"Right, of course. But you keep the promise anyway. That’s what love is. Love is keeping the promise anyway.”

- “What a slut time is. She screws everybody.” 

- “That’s the thing about pain…it demands to be felt.” 
Read More »